Go Back   IKEA FANS > Plan and Design > Kitchen Planning
Register Blogs Forum/Blog Search Mark Forums Read


IKEAFANS Deal of the Month: Find reliable contractors - join Angie’s List today! Use promo code LOCAL to save 15%
Comment
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
No Gallery image is associated with this thread

Old Aug 20th, 09, 5:49 pm   #1
StefJarrell
IKEA FAN
 
Join Date: Aug 4th, 2009
Posts: 97
iKarma: 10,918
Gallery: 1
Location: Annandale, VA
My IKEA: USA-Washington DC:Woodbridge
Doorstyle: Stat
dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

So, I'm coming up with options just in case the ikea panel integrated dishwasher is not forthcoming any time soon.

Any opinions on Thermador vs. Kitchenaid for a panel ready dishwasher? The thing I like better about the KA is that it has a hard food disposal so you don't have to scrape dishes (we have no regular disposal)....

There are bad reviews on the internet for both, but I want real opinions... you can always find complaints on the internet!

thanks

Share |

StefJarrell is offline   Reply With Quote

Register to remove these ads today!

Old Aug 20th, 09, 7:24 pm  
AKA: DulcineaK
GOLD Directory Member
 
Kayla's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 20th, 2006
Posts: 8,146
iKarma: 120,032
Gallery: 110
Location: The hills of El Sobrante
My IKEA: USA-San Francisco:Emeryville
Doorstyle: Rubrik Turq, Fagerland, Tida BB and more!
Blog Entries: 51

LBG Adoptions
Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator 
Total Awards: 10

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

I have owned the KA tall tub for 2 years and I love this machine. Anyone who reads me regularly can testify that I love the KA. You do have to get rid of excess food but you don't have to scrape.... I LOVE the different cycles and the fact that the glass rack raises or lowers. The 3rd rack at the very top for specialty items is great for my knives so my kids never go near them.

I have turned a few clients onto the KA and my mom regrets buying her Bosch now that she's seen the KA in action. I LOVE THIS MACHINE (chuck just told me that my love for my KA is a bit unnatural, but he also agreed that it's a great machine)

I got mine for under $1k which is what the thermador name tag goes for alone, right? I can't speak to the thermador, but I can say I don't ever want a different dishwasher

I have the panel ready one which will eventually have an AGA panel on it to match my future AGA Legacy

Share |
__________________
~Licensed Contractor
formerly Dulci
Visit Kayla's Kitchen Cabinets in the IKEAFANS Directory for info
Kayla is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 20th, 09, 9:16 pm  
IKEA FANS fan!
 
kelly's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 23rd, 2006
Posts: 6,001
iKarma: 41,791
Gallery: 174
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA
My IKEA: USA-Minneapolis:Twin Cities
Doorstyle: Nexus Yellow Brown
Blog Entries: 73

LBG Adoptions
IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation) 
Total Awards: 12

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

I had a KA prior to this move- when we had the opportunity I wanted a concealed control panel, and at that time, it was Bosch only (and I love it). I will say I LOVED MY KA.

I haven't seen Thermador on any lists of "best buys" which isn't to say that they aren't sturdy...just not reviewed. KA is a well known dw brand with many happy customers...if I had to choose, I'd go with the KA panel ready (not sure if thats what you're interested in, just my .02 as styles go in and out, and panel ready will hold up as long as your doors are in style).

Share |
kelly is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 20th, 09, 9:19 pm  
AKA: DulcineaK
GOLD Directory Member
 
Kayla's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 20th, 2006
Posts: 8,146
iKarma: 120,032
Gallery: 110
Location: The hills of El Sobrante
My IKEA: USA-San Francisco:Emeryville
Doorstyle: Rubrik Turq, Fagerland, Tida BB and more!
Blog Entries: 51

LBG Adoptions
Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator 
Total Awards: 10

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

i should maybe say that my mom bought an entry level bosch, which isn't the same tier as my KA, which might add to her reasons for preferring my KA

Share |
__________________
~Licensed Contractor
formerly Dulci
Visit Kayla's Kitchen Cabinets in the IKEAFANS Directory for info
Kayla is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 20th, 09, 9:28 pm  
IKEA FANS fan!
 
kelly's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 23rd, 2006
Posts: 6,001
iKarma: 41,791
Gallery: 174
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA
My IKEA: USA-Minneapolis:Twin Cities
Doorstyle: Nexus Yellow Brown
Blog Entries: 73

LBG Adoptions
IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation) 
Total Awards: 12

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

I had an entry level KA and loved it!! I'd go KA panel ready!!

.

Share |
kelly is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 20th, 09, 11:18 pm  
Moderator, SketchUp Queen
 
zeuss's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 10th, 2007
Posts: 3,334
iKarma: 93,980
Gallery: 77
Location: Vancouver, BC Canada
My IKEA: Canada-Vancouver:Coquitlam
Doorstyle: Tidaholm, Abstrakt Red, Abstrakt White
Blog Entries: 26

LBG Adoptions
Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator  IKEAFANS Builder ($5-$49 Donation) 
Total Awards: 4

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

This news about your Kitchen Aid dishwashers also helps me cheers me up. I spent $$$$$ on my new appiances and I worry that I made the right choice. I've ordered the panel-ready KA drawer. It's going to be so cool to have a drawer as my second dishwasher!

I was going to get a Kitchen Aid warming drawer as well, but their's didn't come panel-ready. So I went with Jenn Air and ordered the panel kit for an extra $59.

Most warming drawers only come in stainless - not much choice.

Share |
__________________
I'm working on my own kitchen. If you want to follow along check out my Project Blog:

Design is not just what it looks like and feels like.
Design is how it works.--Steve Jobs
zeuss is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 21st, 09, 7:05 am  
IKEA FANS fan!
 
kelly's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 23rd, 2006
Posts: 6,001
iKarma: 41,791
Gallery: 174
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA
My IKEA: USA-Minneapolis:Twin Cities
Doorstyle: Nexus Yellow Brown
Blog Entries: 73

LBG Adoptions
IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation) 
Total Awards: 12

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

You're going to love a warming drawer!!

Share |
kelly is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 21st, 09, 10:29 am  
IKEA FAN
 
Join Date: Aug 4th, 2009
Posts: 97
iKarma: 10,918
Gallery: 1
Location: Annandale, VA
My IKEA: USA-Washington DC:Woodbridge
Doorstyle: Stat
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

thanks everyone... the KA it is! My sister actually knew somone who had a thermador and apparnetly with no hard disposal you have to clean some food receptacle, which is beyond gross... I don't mind gross things, but one of my biggest disklikes in the world, is nastly old waterlogged food... I can't see myself cleaning anything out of the bottom of a dishwasher!

I'm so excited!

Oh.. my sis has a KA panel ready, and loves it... she also has a KA two drawer DW for her husbands coffee station... loves that one too!

Share |
StefJarrell is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 21st, 09, 11:51 am  
Moderator, SketchUp Queen
 
zeuss's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 10th, 2007
Posts: 3,334
iKarma: 93,980
Gallery: 77
Location: Vancouver, BC Canada
My IKEA: Canada-Vancouver:Coquitlam
Doorstyle: Tidaholm, Abstrakt Red, Abstrakt White
Blog Entries: 26

LBG Adoptions
Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator  IKEAFANS Builder ($5-$49 Donation) 
Total Awards: 4

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

Wow- your sister put in a 2 drawer dishwasher for a coffee station! That is a lot of coffee cups! What else do they use that area for?

I've noticed that the top drawer is very deep and will hold a ton. That is why I went with a single drawer for my prep and snack area.

I know my big problem is going to be having the discipline to unload the drawer. With the main dishwasher, you have to unload so you can load the next mean away.

But with the drawer, it will not force me as much. I'm a terrible procrastinator so I have to make a point of doing it really regularly. It is no good to me if it is always full of clean bowls, measuring cups, scrapers etc.

Share |
__________________
I'm working on my own kitchen. If you want to follow along check out my Project Blog:

Design is not just what it looks like and feels like.
Design is how it works.--Steve Jobs
zeuss is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Aug 21st, 09, 8:00 pm  
IKEA FANS fan!
 
kelly's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 23rd, 2006
Posts: 6,001
iKarma: 41,791
Gallery: 174
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA
My IKEA: USA-Minneapolis:Twin Cities
Doorstyle: Nexus Yellow Brown
Blog Entries: 73

LBG Adoptions
IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation)  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  Appreciation of an IKEAFAN  IKEAFANS Moderator  IKEAFANS Benefactor ($100+ Donation) 
Total Awards: 12

I've been blogged!
Re: dishwashers: thermador or kitchenaid

Zeuss, you have that exactly right. My longest experience with extra dishdrawers is at my very hard working and successful friend's home, and they have a lot of dishdrawers. The one on the lanai goes unloaded for actual months. The big boy in the butler's pantry as well...This is better than the dishes going unwashed for months!

However, if you actually use that area, you will of course unload it!

Share |
kelly is offline   Reply With Quote


Comment
Top

Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Category Comments Last Post
Discussion of Kitchenaid Drawer Dishwasher pgans Kitchen Appliances 7 Dec 5th, 09 11:37 pm
Kitchenaid Mixer colour question? zeuss Kitchen Planning 26 Aug 26th, 09 7:40 am
Drawer Storage for KitchenAid Hearthgirl Kitchen Planning 1 May 21st, 09 7:49 pm
Dishwasher drawer - Kitchenaid zeuss Modifications 11 Nov 13th, 08 10:57 am
GE Cafe vs KitchenAid architect series bungalowlove Kitchen Appliances 9 Aug 26th, 08 11:27 pm



Subscribe to IKEA News in Your Inbox:

Email:

Featured Kitchen Contractors

Recent Directory Listings

  • iKitchens, Etc.
    We are the premier IKEA Kitchen Installer in Massachusetts. Our company offers complete in-house design service followed by an impeccable installation.
  • Semihandmade
    Custom. IKEA. Doors. The idea for Semihandmade came from a desire to offer the same craftsmanship we produce in our Los Angeles-based Handmade studio to a wider audience, at a lower price.
  • Our House, LLC
    Our House ‘takes the pain’ out of the design and installation process by providing hassle-free service every step of the way. Serving CT and the greater NYC area.
Help an IKEAFAN - Find Threads with Zero Replies